Heist?

Can anything surprise us anymore?  As we all hunker down and attempt to deal with the realities of the omicron surge, another threat to national society is not far from the horizon.  Specifically, as I write, the Lords are debating the Police, Crime, Sentencing and Courts Bill – often dubbed simply the ‘Policing’ Bill.  Last minute amendments by Priti Patel have made the Bill all the more controversial with critics likening it to a power grab worthy of Putin’s Russia or Egypt.

Salient among the justifications are the touted necessity of robust response to the activities of the likes of Insulate Britain and XR, famed for their acts of disruption.  Protestor tactics have changed in recent years, the thinking goes, and the police need the powers to respond effectively.  While there is no doubt that obstructing stretches of motorway, blocking trains into the capital and shutting down various printing presses are far from popular, the case made for the kind of legislation we’re currently looking at tends to gloss over issues as to what constitutes ‘legitimate’ protest, how much power is to be handed over to the Home Secretary and the police and what she and they might – or are perhaps even likely – to do with it.

As Monbiot has pointed out, proposed police powers would include being able to ban anyone from protesting who has previously committed “protest-related offences” or who has even “contributed” to a protest “likely to cause serious disruption”.  If you thought “serious disruption” counted only as sitting on a tube train roof or gluing your face to the M25, consider the breadth of the remit.  If a protest is simply noisy enough to cause “serious unease” it could be banned.  But it is entirely up to officers’ discretion as to how many decibels this might entail and ignores the fact that creating some noise is often half the modus operandi of many given demonstrations.

Other, just as worrying, and imbedded ambiguities remain.  Associating with particular individuals or using the internet to encourage a “protest-related offence” for instance.  And police could effectively impose any restrictions they like on a protest and ban static demonstrations altogether.  Other sweeping statements include mandates against causing “serious disruption to the life of a community” and “serious disruption to the activities of an organisation”.  Stop and search powers could be used without given reason and the legislation as a whole would put many more protestors at risk of arrest.

The problems with this go beyond simply an attack on our rights, as disturbing as this may be.  The Bill would undermine the relationship between police and the public and frequently place impossible choices in the hands of those officers trying to do the right thing.  Relaxing of conditions for stop and search would undoubtably impact even more heavily on ethnic groups and curtailment of protests would hinder the ‘pressure valve’ they have always historically afforded.  Pushing dissent underground and radicalising its expression even further serves no one except, perhaps, those charged with drafting even more stringent legislation in response.

Protest, not unlike the British ‘constitution’ itself has long been subject to certain, generally unclarified, understandings.  Like those of the constitution, these understandings have always been vague, have relied to a large extent on a degree of goodwill or at least the acknowledgement of their likely popularity at large.  But equally, protests have traditionally very often entailed policing costs and a degree of disruption.  To argue otherwise is to endorse their restriction to a saccharine enfeeblement that many charged with managing them would undoubtedly welcome.  There’s always been an element of metaphorical push and shove. 

Given that protestors are often driven by the scale and immediacy of planetary crisis, it’s understandable some of them resort to disruption in the face of apparent media indifference.  But while it is true that (as Digital Rebellion have stated), activism can fill gaps in public awareness left by the press, strategies as to how to bring that public awareness on board are ignored at collective peril.  Though the need for greater traction and swifter change at large is sorely needed, no one should underestimate the extent to which people in general grasp the scale and import of the climate crisis.  The question is not whether we should act but how we should go forward.  And we stand to achieve far more with greater unity.

Activism can only ever be at its most instrumental when coupled with – in service to – wider civic society.  That our ecological situation is urgent, desperate is not in doubt.  It is right that people should find and utilise channels to continue to highlight this, to push for faster and greater change.  We can all lay a hand to that and there is as great a need as ever for those in a position to do so to dedicate themselves.  And mass demonstrations to urge on and hold politicians to account are needed today like never before.

Attempts by our government to clamp down on protest would negate all this.  The PCSC Bill is drafted in a way that would at best cause confusion in its implementation and in all likelihood represents a power grab that must be considered along with other proposed legislation including the Nationality and Borders Bill and ‘amendments’ to the Human Rights Act.  When concern about these laws includes even that of a former prime minister, and in quite forceful terms, the alarm bells for us all should now be ringing. 

Acclaimed film producer and long-standing peer, Lord Puttman, has studied the German descent into fascism in the ‘thirties in some detail and his leaving speech from last October, where he says that we’re in a “very bad place” and need to “wake up” is well worth the read.  With government placemen increasingly embedded in the hearts of our institutions, with broadcasters cautious and cowed and dissent barely more than a whisper, if it were judged alone by bulletins and headlines, it’s more important than ever we stand firm.  For all the fear of diatribes, understandable caution over an undue alarm, the biggest threat we face remains that insulant complacency that clings to the assumption it could never happen here.

Please consider emailing your MP about the Bill and signing this petition.

Twenty Years On

This January marks the twenty year marker since thousands of people from all round the country converged on the Hampshire, Berkshire border for an often gruelling campaign against the Newbury Bypass in particular and new roads in Britain in general. It’s a familiar story by now, or at least ought to be; what can happen when people come together to protest, of how far both sides are prepared to go when a line has been drawn in the sand, of the hope and bitterness, of the inspiration and grinding attrition of states of muted and mutual conflict.

It had gathered a sense of near inevitability by that point; the culmination of years of campaigning and of the desire to push through what was then one of the biggest road building programmes in the UK’s history. There is much you can say, looking back. Certainly the timeliness of doing so probably speaks for itself, with the latest resurgent road building programme; everything that was fought for stands in peril once again; the landscapes and the hope for a manouvre away from ongoing car culture and all its implications for the climate.

That can be banged on about indefinitely and there’s clearly scope and a case for doing so while we are faced with such retrogressive policies. But, if that case ever seems predictable or reductionist, there’s a lot to be said for that time that was about more than simply a battle with the state. If we came to protest, we also came from an instinct simply to gather itself; to live on the land among like minded people and to find as we did a sense of a very real kinship. We came to escape urban life, to make the most of a chance just to live as a people, back in a place we could truly call home.

It was one of the defining, and sometimes tragic, aspects of the time then that people who felt so keenly connected with nature answered their heart’s calling to put themselves right at the front, to fight against and witness what was being done to this country for the sake of apparently insatiable demands for burgeoning infrastructure. Evictions, ongoing actions and more traditional forms of protest all both inspired and took their toll and there are many I know who, while they’d never have had it be another way, left sufficiently scarred just to want to move on.

At the same time, many felt moved to join ongoing movements; against genetic modification, against global free trade and all its repercussions, seeking to cut off the head of the beast rather than fight piece by piece the tentacles each new road represented. At times, along with many more, I’ve sought a return to those kind of days. And they certainly hold a currency of experience and example for anyone protesting now; against new roads or fracking or dubious nuclear deals.

But, while it might sound naïve, there’s a sense too that these protests shouldn’t really be necessary at all. There’s a sense that people shouldn’t have to put their lives and health on the line due to the culpability of governments. That direct action is still a necessary stopgap when official policy seems out of kilter (at best) if not an example of the very worst a state can do (and in this sense the ongoing campaign against fracking couldn’t be more important), there’s also a feeling at times that there is potentially a wider game; that of the potential for mass behavioural change, for the catalysts of a newfound environmental consciousness that need not be necessarily allied to protest overall. Though when lobbyists and corporations still threaten so much, the role of protestors is clearly as needed as ever.

But for my part at least, direct action is no longer an option. The stress of evictions, the minimal food and grinding months of attrition all conspired to mean that activism is a thing I cannot now repeat. And many more find that frontline campaigning can still be too emotionally and psychologically fraught. But while protest is currently crucial, we can remember too that wider stories can persist; of waking up, of how we lead our lives, of how we see to and relate to the world, of what it can feel like to live close to the earth, whether as part of creation or something more immediate; to see her as the relation she is, not some tableau of resources for the taking.

Environmental responsibility starts with every one of us, removed from any sense of ‘us or them’. It can help spark campaigns but can also fuel another sense; what it means to live well and as lightly as we can. Remembering stories can light up our times, but history more often bears echoes of itself rather than perpetuating more exact repetition. People can learn from what happened at Newbury but I also do not doubt that they can be every bit as imaginative and pioneering as anyone involved in the nineties. Ideally there should be no need for division down partisan lines, just as surely as we all have to see our way beyond the machinations of the poorer aspects of the modern world.

Inspiration can take root in many forms. Perhaps what’s needed more than ever is the currency of enabling greater benevolent change, of how a people can be when we hear the call of our hearts as well as that of the planet. In truth of course there’s never really been a separation – the lie that there has been has helped shape so much of our world. Remembering this unity is perhaps the most important, and still urgent, task that we face.

Over the Tarmac: the Spring

If you had to a state a point where the government bid a final farewell to any green credentials, it arguably came with the budgetary autumn review way back in 2011. The 45 road schemes laid out back then have been augmented since by another 150 so that now we seem to be facing a road building programme on a par with the ‘Roads to Prosperity’ schemes of the early nineteen nineties. Those schemes characterised in so many ways the last Conservative government just as the protests against them were symptomatic of wider dissent.

Of the roads planned today, 42 are pretty much direct revivals of those proposed in the ‘nineties and form part of a picture comprised of 76 bypasses, 48 link roads, 12 ring roads with another 60 more minor projects. The whole programme is being estimated at costing around £30 billion. If the figures for the roads built in the previous decade and a half are anything to go by, we can expect a fairly substantial overrun of these early financial projections.

Taken together the roads would affect National Parks, the Norfolk Broads, Areas of Outstanding National Beauty and several World Heritage Sites. They also of course represent a dramatic sea change in transport policy from on high with aspirations to curb car use and promote public transport looking more than a little forlorn. And with road transport emissions accounting for well in advance of twenty percent of UK carbon emissions, the policy effectively scuppers one of the more malleable means by which we can effectively rein these in.

It’s more than a little ironic that vast amounts of cash are being pumped into new infrastructure at a time of austerity so caustic that the upkeep of existing roads is being jeopardized. As a means of funding new roads, the government are looking at schemes such as public-private partnership deals whereby future taxpayers are often lumped with the ‘hidden tolls’ for roads under construction today. But there is still a huge immediate pricetag being picked up by central and local government.

But resistance to all this is growing, most notably with the groups affiliated with the Campaign For Better Transport’s ‘Roads to Nowhere’ campaign. And particularly vigorous protests have been taking place at Combe Haven Valley in opposition to the Bexhill to Hastings Link Road. Earmarked by the DfT themselves as “one of the worst value for money schemes in Britain,” the road’s route has been the scene of incredible acts of front and tenacity as trees have been occupied, camps set up, the less than proverbial bulldozers stopped in their tracks and work effectively delayed for many weeks.

At the time of writing, the DfT have not yet confirmed they will fund their allotted share of the scheme – some £56 million out of a total already spiraling above the £100 million mark. East Sussex County Council are forecast to spend a projected £70 million on the road at a time when it is making wider cuts of the same amount that stand to leave adult social care and children’s services particularly badly hit.

Somehow though, to see the camps spring up, to witness the energy of those making a stand and the sense of release in the process, there seems more in the air than simply a fight against old-school and deviant infrastructure. To go to Combe Haven and see the people in the oaks, to see and hear the pristine valley in the last few days before it’s due to be severed in two, the struggle seems iconic of so many other situations in the wider world. At a time of unprecedented ecological loss, the fact that here in the UK we are losing our ancient woodland at a rate even faster than that impacting the Amazon, any attacks on existing woodland should be more widely recognised for the carnage they really are. And at a time when the government seems deposed to outdo all previous levels of contempt they seem to hold large segments of the population in, there’s something that feels particularly fitting in people staking a common claim in the ground that’s due for destruction and stating enough is enough.

The gruelling conditions on site at Hasting over the previous few months are testament that none of this is necessarily easy. But the rewards for those engaged are clearly evident to see, even in the grip of bitter winter; the knowledge that when people act together there’s a very firm hope for turning round situations that might otherwise prove intractable. But just as the protests of the nineties took years to reach their final culmination, Hastings is just the first major manifestation of the kind of outcry that needs to be taken up more widely if the hydra-like heads of these hundreds of schemes stand any chance of being properly defeated.

This article originally appeared in the spring issue of the Transition Free Press.

Toppling King Coal

The news pops up unmissable, if it weren’t for every other scrap of news also popping at the same time, along with reports of Ann Widdecombe being transported by a showbiz wire above the heads of an incredulous or simple nervous audience on the now worryingly ubiquitous Strictly. So, this particular bit of news says ‘anger was justified’; and this from the former NASA scientist talking about the occupation last year of a coal powered power plant in Ratcliffe-on-Soar near Nottingham by a troupe of activists aiming to shut it down for a week.

The action is a clear case-in-point of a host of issues wider than the heavy handedness of the police response; the right to protest, how this may somehow impinge on wider rights if it means it interferes with the public’s ability to watch Ann Widdecombe – and many more besides – sailing literally or metaphorically with apparent tranquility above the host of disbelieving heads. These millions of mesmerized, vaguely despairing or just bored – a number I could be in on another night – caught in the glare of a mass media that has become both slicker and strangely more popular as it gets ever more debased, suggest we will not think again about our actions even as the savage weather of a dawning century paws with renewed ferocity at the door of our collective consciousness.

And that of course is why those protests took place, why one hundred and fourteen people felt inclined to brave the vagaries of trespass and the response that was bound to come with it. We’re all of us only too aware of the wolf down the road, of the carbon ratcheting up as we hurtle down the motorway of ambivalence towards a fate we all try not to think about. Really, it is not indifference but a kind of collective terror at the situation that we’re in that makes the retreat to the semi fantasy of Saturday night TV seem all the more appealing.

So many now will not join up the dots. The more pronounced the arguments become, the greater the need to take stock of our situation then the greater the temptation not to engage, to turn the other cheek, to ignore the growing feeling that one day soon we will not be able to ignore the rising tides or signs of climatic instability. It is here now, with us, this is the perfect storm, Northern Europe freezes while in Canada and elsewhere the temperature is well above the norm.

But somehow, for the most part, it does not seem so bad. So long as we are warm and have enough to eat we discover our capacity to be content. Sitting virtually incarcerated in cars on the immobilised motorways a thousand motorists turn up the radio and keep their fingers crossed. The more fortunate of us curl up in our living rooms as ice locks us all in and scour our DVD’s and anything else that will help to pass the time and really all of this is only natural; to make the best of any situation. But we seem at times strangely reluctant to not let ourselves really appreciate the nature of our situation, we do not feel inclined to count the cruel tally of the coal as the carbon stacks up from the stacks that churn it out. And partly this is understandable as to do so is to walk along the edge of a kind of precipice looking out over our future, one that does not reassure, an apparently perilous path that could lead us all too easily down a scree or more sudden slope towards despair.

The actions of those at Nottingham in 2009 were of those who chose not to look away, who sought to raise awareness that here, in Britain in the Twentyfirst Century we are rolling on quite happily with the burning of a fuel that is the major cause, besides the oil we use in cars, of anthropocentric driven climate change. Whether we continue to use coal in anything like historic quantities sets up the expectancy or otherwise for any other country in the world to follow in our wake, or set off on another, far more hopeful path.

Of course, it is not enough to beat our chests and sing out; “let there be no more burning of coal.” We have to take stock of the truly huge scale of the problem, of how much we are reliant of this source of fuel, of how comparably unreliable alternative sources of energy can be when providing the necessary base load capacity to enable sixty one million viewers to turn on their kettles in the breaks between Ann’s airbourne debuts on the box. The answers are there but they require both political will and appropriate investment.

In the recent court case, it was argued that seeking to engage the public by encouraging the use of less power on certain days would have been a more constructive response. But, as James Hansen argued, we need to leave the stuff in the ground, not merely moderate our use of it. In that sense taking on a government policy where coal is all but mandatory looks alot more credulous.

Speaking on a debate on Radio Four recently, George Monbiot defined a crucial element of justification of any protest as one of accountability, of surrendering yourself to the full force of the law if you are to break it, in the belief that your actions will be tried in a court, that the rightness of your cause will meet the rigors of the legal system and have the chance to be vindicated in the process. As I understand it, the protestors at Ratcliffe were planning to lock on en masse; in this, they had made the decision to have their beliefs put to just such a test and in the process to present themselves as accountable for their deeds.

However much such protests may make us uncomfortable, they remain, at their best, a simple articulation of an article of a clarified awareness. Whether or not shutting down power stations is the best way to go about it, even an action like this can serve to remind us that things are wrong, that we cannot afford to sit by in denial or complacency while we betray the future through the failure to acknowledge that there must be change, that whatever the complexity, whatever psychological mires we may face, we are at a turning point and must look for and continue to express our expectations that we can moderate our impact on this earth, that we remain – to a possibly still crucial degree – the masters of our destiny if we can only see it.

No Oil But Dirty Oil

Some things strip away the camouflage and leave the very ugly truth just staring back, unshamed. Suddenly the hopes are gone that somehow we might struggle through the end of the age of cheap oil even though it represents a monumental challenge. Or rather the conditions of such hopes become much clearer; that all such efforts will be totally in vain if we do nothing to prevent the onslaught facing our remaining indigenous peoples and the land that they protect. They are threatened by the corporations that effectively dictate the currents of our Northern policies, that are now rushing at full tilt into securing the resources a rapaciously expanding economy demands.

What’s clear is that those in these corporations that – as the recent article in the Washington Post confirms even Obama’s administration has been to a very large degree in deference to – will stop at nothing to do what must be done to feed the mindset and reality of an industrial dream long since turned sour. And those that stand to suffer most; who are even now in many places fighting for the very right to live, are those who have done the least damage, who are infact light years in everything they do from those patterns of thought and behaviour that are so surely selling us right down the river.

Suddenly it all comes crowding in, the floodgates are unleashed, an awful clarity arrives; the people in Ecuador suffering records rates of cancer thanks to the activities of Texaco, the very water that they drink and wash in poisoned by the run off from substandard oil sumps so that their children suffer horrific lesions, the ground itself so polluted that their poultry and their dogs simply keel over. Waking up to the scale and extent of what is now well underway in Canada is equally horrific; a realisation that what is planned for the tar sands of North Alberta will probably make that region uninhabitable in another fifty years.

Add the ever-spreading travesty within the Gulf of Mexico, think about the lapse in regulations that helped to lead to such a tragedy occurring and there can be no doubt that those who profit from oil also do so from a truly diabolical contribution to our collective fate. And they will not be stopped by governments, by wishful thinking, by their laying down to accept that the show is really over, that they will have to grow up and get used to finite resources on a finite planet. They will not stop by any volition of their own. They will not simply ruin or take the lives of nearly every people living in accord with any kind of ancient harmony. They will not simply remove what hope remains of our ever building something better than our outgrown industrial model as we endeavour to remould our cultures and societies. They stand to remove our last real chances of our ever leaving a biosphere that will not have reached the tipping points, that can still be classed as habitable or which would enable such a thing under something other than the direst circumstances. If we do not act we will only witness so many countries running even further out of water, or which are either fried beneath the anvil of an ever more intolerable sun or have been swallowed beneath the waves that only echo the despondency that stands to let this happen.

Out of our own humanity if nothing else we must all wean ourselves off our extravagance of oil. We must not shy from holding up a mirror to our Western world, to the cars we nearly all see as a right, the planes that are now almost mandatory to many. It is not fashionable. There is a faint embarrassment in crying out too loud, in scaring off all those who would be sympathetic to our cause. But what price does pandering to such sympathy entail? This is no joke or abstract wishing well of good intentions that bears little resemblance to real life. This goes further even than seeking to preserve our here and now, our own green hills and valleys – as intrinsic in their understated way to the big picture as they are. This is the ideal that we must wake up to and the earth herself is attempting to shake us by the throat. But the dream we are caught up in – and it is one that holds us in its very real concerns and even snares – almost seems to know this and raises the pitch of her siren-like voice.

We must find our way beyond it, we must wake up to the other story that we lost so long ago and whose importance now could not be greater. The longer we leave it, the more our denial is written in blood. For the scale of the horror we are all responsible for, look to the jungles of Ecuador, try to imagine the cries of people who have had no part in contributing to this mess, who – from Russia to Papua New Ginea to Nigeria – are now fighting for their lives and that of the land they have lived truly lightly on.

We must wake up. We really know on every level that we are in trouble but seek to block it out, to let our lives hold to their current course because this requires less effort, because we are caught up in the momentum of several centuries of change that let us think we could play God. Our awakening must be as much as anything from the forces of despair and apathy and must bring us into not only a greater perception of the nature of the problem; it must bring us into a greater sense of our own power, of what we can achieve despite all odds. Even the most glorious of summers, even the strongest sense of peace will not lead us clear if we do not confront the paradigm that seeks to keep our future from us and which vast leagues of speculators serve, blindly or recklessly or simply caught by love of money and the power it appears to bring but which ultimately leaves you all the weaker if in it’s acquisition you have lost so much that once was precious.

The scale of the challenge is nothing short of monumental. It is already one of several fields – the often literal coalface in the most unspoiled regions of the world being the most obvious and perhaps the most pressing and extreme. But also we are challenged in what we permit to pass within our nations’ borders – however much such borders must be held in perspective with the growing volkerwanderung we all now face, however much we cling to the comforts of a passing age. We must too challenge everything about our own behaviour, about how we relate to our land and localities. We must above all never think we are incapable or unworthy of the task that has been set us.

Everything we love lies in the balance and this is not the time to sit back, cross our fingers and hope for the best. We must all act to the best of our potential. It is for every one of us to play our part. And to do so we must step away from our screens for a while, think what it is like to lose your land and health and loved ones and remember this is not some tubthumped doomsday that may come if our elected politicians do not save us. It is already the reality for a growing number of First Nation peoples to whom we all owe a massive debt of gratitude, who hold so much knowledge that can inform the nature of the way ahead. We owe it to them to re-evaluate our every shared assumption, our every scrap of received wisdom: our own survival rests upon their fate, as does that which still remains of our morality.

Another World is Possible

One day last November I walked up the hill that I grew up on, took the old track that ran along the ridge, full of flints, passed the woods I’d spent so many hours in long years back, looking up into the ash trees young and old. A mile or so further on along the ridge, I stopped and properly took things in. I was at the end of an old cut through the side of the hill. It was said to be Neolithic and hugged the contours, almost in deference to the hill itself rather than smashing its way through, an imprint but within a scale that seemed almost part of a natural order. It felt like the beginnings of winter; cold but not that cold, the hills all full of haze and mist, the greens and golds all given up to blues and greys and brown.

Somehow though it felt substantial in itself, like winter was a mantle that was somehow warm as well as rich. It spoke of fires and the smell of woodsmoke caught upon the street, of company and comradeship. Here in the lee of the hill you could hear the wind but barely feel it and it added to the sense of peace, of being somewhere removed from all the rush and non-stop headiness. The feeling of tranquillity was tangible in a way I had not felt for years and the sense of dual strength and gentleness surprised me. I thought again of Hardy, of his poem of the thrush, of hope and changing seasons.

Even the pylons snaking their way across the Downs seemed almost homely up here, momentarily, and I thought again of the last time I had lived here, one bitter winter with a badly broken collar bone and the burgeoning idea for a book about roads. I’d left behind me many friends in Nottingham, falling off the bike had marked a parting of the ways but the memory of all the times and friends I’d known still stood clear in my mind and in my dreams. Things had seemed to chime in in some strange sort of way whenever I’d gone up there. People were warm and expansive and it was clearly not for nothing that they called this the heart of the country.

But it was interesting in other, less obvious ways. It was part of the cradle of the industrial revolution, the river valleys there were once full of blossoming cotton mills, what happened in the Midlands and much further north helped determine the future of the world for centuries to come. But also, among the obvious accolade of stories of the Forest and its righteous outlaws, there was the story of Nedd Ludd and his followers, rising up against the wave of mills and their machines. With talk of a huge expansion of tree planting of the now somewhat nominal Forest, together with adverts for the future of industry in the region in the station as I arrived, I knew at once what my friend meant when he said important battles had been waged here.

There were many things that made their mark during the time I spent up there; sunlight on the water in the Spring, a quality to it that is even now hard to define, the water filling up a disused gravel pit, now made a lake on a nature reserve. There was also the company of good old friends, of promise for the future. But there was much more; the starlight on the bits of quartz-like pebbles on the track in the woods at the back of the old mining village some friends of mine called home. Hawks from the hill in sunset, the orange gold just showing through in bands beneath the clouds as if in token of what might lie in store.

And then there were the rooks; a vast and spreading army in the woods, tumbling through the clouds and scraps of blue and silver in the October sky over the green of the village, keeping vast council in the remnants of the Forest. It was like the coloured hoods of my friends and the black mantles of the rooks were almost synonymous, the heart of the woods in winter both brooding and benevolent.

These were friends from Newbury and the ties were strong as any family. On my first visit they were setting up a social centre and looking at a massive house to set up in. I had dreams of both places later, Betjamen checking them out from under a hat made from folded newspaper, the kitchens in the basement busy with the foundations of some kind of new world order. For years, for me, it was an anchor point, my point of home and the strongest connection to the counter culture I was still just about a part of. While I was no longer at that point particularly politically engaged, it meant a lot to be somehow in connection with it all, there seemed a continuity that was at least symbolic.

And though I have since returned to a corner of this southern county, I cannot help but salute everything old friends still choose to represent, just as I watch the movement rolling on, evolving first into the anti-capitalist demos, later to the Climate Camps. Perhaps there is a danger in putting too much faith in protest as the one and only means to the way forward. It has a massive role to play but can never be the only answer. What’s really needed now more than anything is a greater acknowledgement that we are all in this mess together and must find our way beyond it bonded by the knowledge of the common problem; a world whose biosphere is on the brink, whose store of cheap energy that has placed our lifestyles on a kind of pedestal for so long is beginning to run dry.

Protest can sometimes be portrayed as counterproductive to the cultivation of this sense of shared predicament. But to deny the role it has to play is to underestimate the forces that have such a massive impact on our daily lives. We need to change direction en masse and protest can be the necessary nudge to those in high places who would not choose to do so otherwise. Its necessity is defined by its opposite; the mentality that says nothing is wrong even as we helter skelter to a day that will at the very least be a monumental challenge. Even if it achieves nothing but communicating the sense that we are sleepwalking and that we must wake up, protest can constitute an alarm call that we need as badly now as ever.

And so the knowledge of good people gives me hope, just as there is hope in the far flung places, a hope informed perhaps of nothing but endurance, of the places waiting for us to come back to them, to mark them on our wanders on a winter’s day, to take that feeling back with us and hold it dear, before we are enfolded once again by media and chatter or maybe just the steady warmth of common human company.

It is this that bolsters my expectations for what we are faced with, that – just as we must live with whatever the future may hold – there are many who can help to lead the way, whose vision is formed of far more than some list of endless anti’s; they hold the cradle of the way ahead, of what it means to show some faith in the kind of world we could still bring about. Beneath the glacial tip of vocal protest there is a groundswell that is growing every day; of taking responsibility for what we eat or otherwise consume, for what we grow, for how we engage in the political spheres on even microcosmic levels, for how we can help foster what remains or can be revived of our communities.

It is perhaps a longshot, the faith it shows is maybe bloodyminded. But it is an attitude, a stance that says we will not turn our backs on future generations, on what survives around the corner, on communities a thousand miles away threatened by eviction for mines that only feed our dependence on a sea of pointless crap. The feelings of conviction I am trying to describe are inspired by a sense of what lies on the line and a sense of hope for what may lie in store.

This is something Hardy may have understood and perhaps he would be have been heartened that there are those who have the opportunity to do more than mourn the passing of the days, who strive to hold onto the personal, onto what is immediate and real, as well as call in a vision of how things could hopefully still be.

Returning through the woods the other day, the rooks were also coming home, calling out in their massed numbers as they passed above the trees, speaking of journeys, of what was coming in, of fondness and belonging. Maybe you will hear them if you wander in the hollows and high places. Maybe their song will help to lift your heart, despite the trials of the times that we are faced with, maybe their chorus can stir us to meet the much maligned but somehow still decipherable promise that tomorrow holds if we can only listen to her call.

Torch Bearers

You could see it like a gash on the horizon, beginnings of embankments marked in white from all the Dorset chalk. It was only too familiar but far too sad to see by any measure; now it seems another road by yet another backward looking council is advancing at full tilt and all the trials of those who’ve tried to stop it have come to nothing. Like England is scarred now not by almighty programmes from on high, but piecemeal, prosaically, facilitated by a trough of ill advise or apathy.

Dorset County Council – the ones who’ve pushed this road from the beginning – state on their own website that Dorset’s coast and countryside is amongst the most varied and beautiful in England and is believed by many to be the County’s most important asset. Thanks to Thomas Hardy, its hinterland is of international renown and it is where that hinterland meets the coast, where the ridge that makes it way down from the heartland plateau of Salisbury Plain, that the full damage of the road becomes quite clear.

As I write the scar grows ever wider and a line of hills that stretches up past Wiltshire to Ivinghoe Beacon on the Chilterns, a line that forms the backbone of the country, has now been desecrated for the sake of dubious expediency. The road had been proposed for nearly twenty years with high levels of local support, given that they were told that it would solve the town’s congestion even though, as Natural England stated in their objection at the road’s public inquiry; “[the scheme’s] advantages are limited and likely to be achievable in large measure by other means.”

The very need for the scheme was questioned by both The Council for the Protection of Rural England and the Woodland Trust. This was brushed aside by both the Council and the Planning Inspector however as if the presence of unquestionable congestion justified tackling this through increasing road space; a mock solution that had been discredited more than a decade ago. The adoption of such a pseudo solution today points to either an absolute absence of vision, endemic crookedness, sheer stupidity or perhaps simply the inability to convince a population that another road will not change anything, other than lock us in further to a pattern of environmental degradation and the cultural loss that comes with it.

There were other casualties besides the ridge. Two Mile Coppice – a patch of woodland and part of a SSSI – has now been carved up, effectively depriving the town of a much loved walking spot. It was the only remaining piece of ancient woodland within the Borough of Weymouth and Portland and, like all ancient woodland, had taken centuries to evolve. Compare this with the ‘mitigation’ package that somehow justifies the tearing in two of a nature reserve; the offer of the use of a piece of secondary woodland half a mile away, cut off from the town now by the road and containing only a fraction of the richness of the habitat, offered to console or otherwise entice the owners of Two Mile Coppice – The Woodland Trust – whose many objections at the inquiry were rebuffed with breathtaking simplicity by Dorset County Council. Amongst other things, the Council stated that the benefits outweigh the harm and that the secondary woodland could be an equal or greater resource, like pieces of land are theirs to carve up, like doling out one plot can justify the annihilation of the other.

And this, in echoes of other SSSI’s destroyed or damaged right across the country, has taken place despite national, regional and local legislation, including the Natural Environmental and Rural Communities Act and the UK Biodiversity Action Plan. English Heritage at any rate did not object, were happy with a payout that enabled a survey of the barrows on the portion of ridge that soon would no longer exist.

There was also the dissecting of a local housing estate which – among the predictable disadvantages of forced relocation, division of community, noise and air pollution – meant that many well used cycle routes away from the main roads are now impossible to use. Other land destroyed, damaged or rendered semi-sterile by the noise and toxicity of passing cars includes Dorset Wildlife Trust’s Lorton Meadows Nature Reserve and an and area designated of Local Landscape Interest. Bincombe Valley and its peace has now been lost. Add to this the marring of enjoyment of well known and well used long distance footpaths; Wey Valley Walks, the Dorset Jubilee Trail, the South West Coast Path itself and it’s clear the building of this road is a full blown tragedy.

Why was it built? Who funded it? How did it come to pass that it was allowed to go ahead? As I’ve already mentioned, there was strong local support for the scheme among much – but clearly not all – of Weymouth’s population. And – as also mentioned earlier – it reflects too the growing gap between local and national governmental thinking. This is partly a reflection of the engineering background of many County Council planning men, which fundamentally skews their entire mentality. It also tells of the kind of money that is still available for big schemes like roads and bridges, even trams on better years. Small scale and smart schemes – workplace and school travel plans, more cycle paths, car clubs – these things do not possess the same appeal for many councillors as large and slick construction contracts, are perhaps harder to sell as ‘doing something’, do not appear to carry the flame of ‘legacy.’ The big irony, considering the much promulgated Green Team Great Britain is that this road was partly funded, and largely justified by the 2012 Olympics, Weymouth hosting the yatching events for the occasion.

The coming disaster was acknowledged by the turnout of those already mentioned who objected to the scheme at the inquiry. But, in a saddening echo of the eighties and nineties, it was by then a largely foregone conclusion. There were others who stepped in, a man called Noddy who set up camp in an oak in Two Mile Coppice in the freezing cold of mid December, who was joined by others but by far too few. And yet they held the promise of what’s needed, of what in other times and places has come to pass and could still do so again. The flame at Two Mile Coppice was shortlived, but the ember of dissent the symbol of that protest holds could still be carried for what lies ahead.

It is tragic that at such a time, with the carbon impact of road transport only all too clear that a strong resurgent movement casts off as unfashionable or strategically second place the fight against the forces of road building. What makes Weymouth no less tragic, and which should make it stand as a bitter but vital reminder, is that we know we can fight – and win – against road building and on a national level, which should make taking on local councils relatively easy.

Thomas Hardy made the landscape of West Dorset famous in his time, a fame that lives today around the world. And it was a love for landscape that moved me and many more to join the protests against roads when we did. Global warming almost seemed abstract then against the all too real and visible butchery of hills that was taking place around us. For me the feeling still holds; not one issue over another because, in many ways, they are inseparable. The feeling holds not just through the corresponding tally of road transport to emissions, or the pathological degree of insulation from our natural surroundings when travelling in a car. The state of today’s and tomorrow’s climate is perhaps to some extent a reflection of how we treat our landscapes and our hills. The scientific consensus we now have over emissions is of course of indispensable value. But we should not be too quick to dismiss finer sentiments, the undersung feelings of belonging and connection, of living up to a feeling of greater responsibility.

As the saying goes, what we do to the land we do to ourselves. This is in no small part reflected in the writings of Hardy who was in his way somehow married to the land. His work speaks of lovers looking out for one another as one rounded a track on the side of a hill, reddle men making their way over down and heath for days like they were almost aboriginal in their intimacy with the ground below and all around them. Figures on the skyline fading with the light, stood on barrows that were in themselves like tiny, smaller hills upon the back of larger ones when you saw them from any kind of distance. He describes an intenseness of connection where a place is more than just personified. It is in it’s way like a world, represents and actually carries a force, holds a character that encompasses the other lesser figures so that their passions reflect the feeling of the place that they inhabit, seem almost trivial by comparison or somehow lifted up and made a part of the wider scene. At his best, he evokes some sense of common blood, of common destiny running through both place and the people upon it so that the stories of love and betrayal, of tragedy and whatever scraps of redemption can be found in hearts of sadness seem somehow of a greater order, a pattern that cannot be totally defined but somehow sits there with us.

Hardy’s greatest poem, or at least the one that has stayed with me above the rest, was ‘The Darkling Thrush’ in which he describes listening to the bird, in the twilight on a December’s evening at the beginning of the twentieth century. It ends;

So little cause for carolings

Of such ecstatic sound

Was written on terrestrial things

Afar or nigh around,

That I could think there trembled through

His happy good-night air

Some blessed Hope, whereof he knew

And I was unaware.

Today, with the world Hardy knew and sought to preserve in collective memory seemingly vanished it is our charge to somehow constitute a move back towards something that resembles the best that it contained. There may still be hope for this, for the kind of world we still will have some say in, but not if more roads like Weymouth’s are officially approved and widely ignored. We must keep hold of our hills, cherish them in the full knowledge that life depends upon their preservation. They hold more than our past and sense of place; they keep our very future and hold the power to awake, even when – horrifically but nonetheless especially – they have been taken from us. Weymouth’s loss can remind us of everything there still remains to fight for. We should do so while hope for so many more places persists.